Who could replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United?

Illustration of Michael Carrick with Mauricio Pochettino, Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann at Old Trafford.

Mauricio Pochettino is preparing the U.S. men’s national team for a Nations League quarterfinal against Haiti. He’s also one of three coaches linked with Manchester United as the club reviews Michael Carrick’s future.

The Athletic reports that United are expected to dismiss Carrick, although the club maintains that no final decision has been made.

Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann are both out of work. Pochettino has a team to pick and a contract with U.S. Soccer through 2030.

The pressure on Carrick grew after United needed two goals in stoppage time to draw 4–4 with Aston Villa. They’d already come from 2–0 down to beat Roma in Europe, but they’ve gone eight league games without a win and sit 18th.

Carrick remains in charge while director of football Jason Wilcox reviews his position. United’s next match is at Liverpool on Nov. 22. The break gives the club time to weigh its options, with little time for a new coach to work with the full squad before Anfield.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Stadio United (@stadiounited)

United considered Pochettino in 2022 before appointing Erik ten Hag. It’s easy to see why he’d come up again. His Tottenham teams pressed high and used their fullbacks to give players like Christian Eriksen and Dele Alli room to receive the ball inside.

He took Spurs to a Champions League final, and in his one season at Chelsea, they finished sixth. For a United side that can score in bursts but has struggled to control matches, the appeal is a coach who’s built Premier League teams that can keep opponents pinned back.

The U.S. hired Pochettino in 2024 with less than two years to prepare for a home World Cup. This time, he’s signed up for the next USMNT cycle from the beginning.

The federation renewed his deal after the U.S. beat Bosnia and Herzegovina 2–0 for its first World Cup knockout win since 2002.

Under the new agreement, he and his staff will also advise on youth development and coach education. If he left, U.S. Soccer would have to replace its senior coach just as it starts putting that broader plan into practice.

The Haiti tie is the first competitive assignment of that new cycle. The first leg is in Miami on Nov. 14 and the return is in Cincinnati on Nov. 17. Pochettino has recalled Christian Pulisic, Weston McKennie and Folarin Balogun for the tie, their first call-ups since the World Cup.

The terms remain private, and a formal United approach is unconfirmed.

What Eddie Howe and Julian Nagelsmann would bring

Eddie Howe has the most directly comparable rescue job on his résumé. Newcastle were still looking for their first league win when he arrived in November 2021. They finished 11th, helped by a January window that brought in Kieran Trippier, Dan Burn and Bruno Guimarães.

Howe later took Newcastle into the Champions League twice and won the League Cup. He stepped down in July, and Wilcox is reported to favor him if United make a change.

Howe’s teams could hurt opponents the moment they won the ball back. Newcastle scored 12 Premier League goals from high turnovers in 2023–24, second only to Manchester City. That approach requires the players behind the first presser to close off the obvious passes.

If United’s front line jumps while the midfield stays deep, opponents can play through the gap. Howe has shown he can teach a team to press together, though his Newcastle recovery also shows how much a good January window can help.

Julian Nagelsmann has been out of work since leaving Germany after the World Cup. He won the Bundesliga with Bayern Munich and reached a Champions League semifinal with RB Leipzig. Christopher Vivell, United’s head of recruitment, is reported to rate him highly.

Leipzig’s flexibility was one of the reasons they could compete deep into Europe. Nagelsmann could change how his team built up or pressed without having to change personnel.

That could help United get more out of the same squad. The trade-off is how quickly players learn the responsibilities that come with those switches. If a wide defender steps forward, someone has to cover the space he leaves.

If the midfield changes shape in possession, players still have to know who protects the middle when the ball is lost. A midseason appointment would give Nagelsmann fewer training sessions to teach those details before they’re tested in games.

Howe’s case rests on having organized a Premier League side in immediate trouble. Nagelsmann offers more ways to reshape a team without waiting for new players.

Pochettino has rebuilt in England before, but there are two calendars to reckon with.

The USMNT’s second leg against Haiti is five days before United go to Anfield. If Old Trafford comes calling, Pochettino would have to weigh that job against a World Cup cycle he’s only just begun.

Get more Stadio United on Google.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top